Re: [Freeswitch-dev] mod managed, cant receive events thru EventReceivedFunction callback
Hi, I would like to raise this question again since it doesn't seem to have an answer yet. I built a .NET module which implements IAppPlugin and IApiPlugin. I looked at the /contrib/verifier/eventsocket and it is actually the client to connect to FS through mod_event_socket (correct me if I'm wrong here). I believe Andrew's concern was how to receive events through EventReceivedFunctionCallback but not connect to FS and receive event via TCP/IP. I would want to implement a .NET module that acts like an endpoint. Could someone show me the direction of how to hook up handlers like it is done in native C++? How would I read the incoming audio data and how would I send audio as an outgoing stream. I setup the .NET module and dial plan so that the Run() method in my module is invoked whenever a call is bridged to my endpoint. The ParkingLot and Demo script sample does enlighten me a little but I still have no clue how would I go about the audio stream after I call session.Answer(). Any help would be greatly appreciated. Best Regards Alex To
Basically, if you want to do something that's not "made easy" for language plugins, you just do it the C way, like any other FreeSWITCH C module. The mod_managed swig wrappers expose nearly every function. The difficult part is that some of the indirect types (pointers to types and function pointers) aren't swig'd very nicely, and just have a wrapper class such as "SWIGTYPE_p_foo_t". In this case, you're required to create the backing structure however required, then get a pointer to that structure and wrap it in the SWIGTYPE_p_xxx class. If your backing structure is a .NET type, you can use GCHandle to get an IntPtr to it. Or you can directly allocate memory via the Marshal class and use that IntPtr. This is likely to be annoying and a lot of work. It's only really easy for function pointers, as all you need to do is declare a delegate, attribute it [UnmanagedFunctionPointer(CallingConvention.Cdecl)], then call Marshal.GetFunctionPointerForDelegate. The runtime will emit unmanaged stubs that will handle unmanaged-managed transitioning and give you a nice C compatible function pointer you can wrap and pass around. You can see some examples in ManagedSession.cs. Additionally, the SWIGTYPE_p_xxx classes don't have public constructors, so the FSUtil class provides this extension method on IntPtr: public static T CreateSwigTypePointer<T>(this IntPtr cPtr) That way you can create the wrapper classes as needed after you've created the structures and wrapped them up. In summary, it's possible to create an endpoint module from C#, but a major PITA. You should consider either using a mixed-mode language such as C++/CLI or write a helper library in C/C++ and export that via swig. We'd welcome contributions to mod_managed that simplify access to a set of the FS APIs. -Michael From: freeswitch-dev-bounces@lists.freeswitch.org [mailto:freeswitch-dev-bounces@lists.freeswitch.org] On Behalf Of Alex To Sent: Monday, November 02, 2009 5:19 AM To: freeswitch-dev@lists.freeswitch.org Subject: Re: [Freeswitch-dev] mod managed, cant receive events thru EventReceivedFunction callback Hi, I would like to raise this question again since it doesn't seem to have an answer yet. I built a .NET module which implements IAppPlugin and IApiPlugin. I looked at the /contrib/verifier/eventsocket and it is actually the client to connect to FS through mod_event_socket (correct me if I'm wrong here). I believe Andrew's concern was how to receive events through EventReceivedFunctionCallback but not connect to FS and receive event via TCP/IP. I would want to implement a .NET module that acts like an endpoint. Could someone show me the direction of how to hook up handlers like it is done in native C++? How would I read the incoming audio data and how would I send audio as an outgoing stream. I setup the .NET module and dial plan so that the Run() method in my module is invoked whenever a call is bridged to my endpoint. The ParkingLot and Demo script sample does enlighten me a little but I still have no clue how would I go about the audio stream after I call session.Answer(). Any help would be greatly appreciated. Best Regards Alex To
Oh thank you Michael for answering all my dumb questions. :D I agree with you Interoperability between unmanaged and managed code is such a PITA. I think I am going back to C++ module for the moment since the unmanaged API isn't "made easy" in managed code yet. If I have the time later, I will go back and read the managed part, hopefully I could contribute to the managed part in FS. Regards Alex To From: freeswitch-dev-bounces@lists.freeswitch.org [mailto:freeswitch-dev-bounces@lists.freeswitch.org] On Behalf Of Michael Giagnocavo Sent: Monday, November 02, 2009 8:34 PM To: freeswitch-dev@lists.freeswitch.org Subject: Re: [Freeswitch-dev] mod managed, cant receive events thru EventReceivedFunction callback Basically, if you want to do something that's not "made easy" for language plugins, you just do it the C way, like any other FreeSWITCH C module. The mod_managed swig wrappers expose nearly every function. The difficult part is that some of the indirect types (pointers to types and function pointers) aren't swig'd very nicely, and just have a wrapper class such as "SWIGTYPE_p_foo_t". In this case, you're required to create the backing structure however required, then get a pointer to that structure and wrap it in the SWIGTYPE_p_xxx class. If your backing structure is a .NET type, you can use GCHandle to get an IntPtr to it. Or you can directly allocate memory via the Marshal class and use that IntPtr. This is likely to be annoying and a lot of work. It's only really easy for function pointers, as all you need to do is declare a delegate, attribute it [UnmanagedFunctionPointer(CallingConvention.Cdecl)], then call Marshal.GetFunctionPointerForDelegate. The runtime will emit unmanaged stubs that will handle unmanaged-managed transitioning and give you a nice C compatible function pointer you can wrap and pass around. You can see some examples in ManagedSession.cs. Additionally, the SWIGTYPE_p_xxx classes don't have public constructors, so the FSUtil class provides this extension method on IntPtr: public static T CreateSwigTypePointer<T>(this IntPtr cPtr) That way you can create the wrapper classes as needed after you've created the structures and wrapped them up. In summary, it's possible to create an endpoint module from C#, but a major PITA. You should consider either using a mixed-mode language such as C++/CLI or write a helper library in C/C++ and export that via swig. We'd welcome contributions to mod_managed that simplify access to a set of the FS APIs. -Michael From: freeswitch-dev-bounces@lists.freeswitch.org [mailto:freeswitch-dev-bounces@lists.freeswitch.org] On Behalf Of Alex To Sent: Monday, November 02, 2009 5:19 AM To: freeswitch-dev@lists.freeswitch.org Subject: Re: [Freeswitch-dev] mod managed, cant receive events thru EventReceivedFunction callback Hi, I would like to raise this question again since it doesn't seem to have an answer yet. I built a .NET module which implements IAppPlugin and IApiPlugin. I looked at the /contrib/verifier/eventsocket and it is actually the client to connect to FS through mod_event_socket (correct me if I'm wrong here). I believe Andrew's concern was how to receive events through EventReceivedFunctionCallback but not connect to FS and receive event via TCP/IP. I would want to implement a .NET module that acts like an endpoint. Could someone show me the direction of how to hook up handlers like it is done in native C++? How would I read the incoming audio data and how would I send audio as an outgoing stream. I setup the .NET module and dial plan so that the Run() method in my module is invoked whenever a call is bridged to my endpoint. The ParkingLot and Demo script sample does enlighten me a little but I still have no clue how would I go about the audio stream after I call session.Answer(). Any help would be greatly appreciated. Best Regards Alex To
participants (2)
-
Alex To
-
Michael Giagnocavo